- Gadolhadorah, I’m not sure what happened while I was wrinting my previous comment, I may have pressed submit and it will show up soon, incompleted.
I don’t see anything submitted other than this post -33
I also belive that Joseph will bring more sources supporting his OPINION but since he is denying that there are many great Rabbonim saying the opposite than he is trying to prove, I will therefore not be directly responding to his posts with his “proof” because I can’t argue when someone who is dishonest. I am not claiming that his sources saying a women must obey her husband is incorrect, I am just discussing in which context it means. As we know, this issue is not black and white where one can make a blanket statement that women are subservient to their husbands.
And pesukim straight out of the Torah, without the meforshim to explain what they mean, in most instances, do not show clear, relevent halacha. That’s how the Karuim ended up completely irrelevant today and they are not considered Jews anymore because they “paskened” halacha from Tanach. We cannot pasken halacha without input and clarity from our great Rabbis.
Therefore, because of his denying that sources exist that prove and pasken that women are not owned by men and by quoting pesukim from the Torah that don’t prove halacha but can be TEITCHED whichever way he chooses to, at this point I will not address my arguments directly to him.