Reply To: Isn’t Smoking אסור?!?!?!

Home Forums Local & Neighborhood Issues Isn’t Smoking אסור?!?!?! Reply To: Isn’t Smoking אסור?!?!?!

#1540333
Health
Participant

yitzchokm – “Health,
You say??????!????
And YOU are????
You sound like Tendler, spewing nonsense that R Moshe WOULD HAVE said knowing today’s medical advances, THAT brain-dead is halachic death. Nonsense.”

No, I didn’t even learn in YU!
The Little I Know quoted R’ D. Feinstein – I’ll repeat from above:
“R’ Dovid shlit”a stated, the teshuvah was based on the data available and provided at that time. With today’s data, the psak is clearly ossur.”

So tell me – is it only by Smoking that you hold like R’ Moshe & Dayan Fisher or you always go with the Yochid against the Rabim, in every case?!?