Reply To: Carlebach niggunim

Grosserchacham, I really just wanted to know the justification of people, who already disagree with his actions and m.o. That’s why I tried to keep it to black hat, vs ultra right wing like an aggudah type shul. Both groups aren’t the typical carlebach type. Certainly if you there is no problem with carlebach there’s nothing to talk about. Thjis is specifically a question for people who do not stand at all with carlebach but are more than happy to sing his kabbolos shabbos. Don’t kid yourself into thinking I’m the first to raise this point, it’s no smear campaign. I’m sorry this has offended you