Home › Forums › Bais Medrash › Minhagim › Chanuka Menorah › Reply To: Chanuka Menorah
@putdownthegun- Well,of course you’re “not sure” what my point is since you are a prime example of the brainwashed propaganda spewing lubavitcher. My “point” is, that befitting to your word twisting agenda, you tried throwing this “false Menorah” war on the “crazy meshichists” when in fact it has nothing to do with them and showed “respectable rabbonim” (in the eyes of lubavitchers).
That particular article is from 2012 so what? There have been many other articles and talks about this subject for years later and would be on the front page of col immediately if the topic would be suggested. So lets not try to dismiss it just because this in particular was written in 2012. I suggest you look at the comments as well while your at it. The point is that this is the view of chabad regardless of col articles or not.
And my point all along was that there are many Jewish proofs of the menorah being curved branches and even YY Jacobson(a chabad rabbi/speaker) has said that the Bayis Sheini the Menorah was curved branches.
I also suggest you look deep into seforim teaching about bein adam lechaveiro which you guys obviously have none of by mocking the rest of the Yiddishe worlds minhagim. Also I suggest you look into your own chabad theme of “Bittul”, since you can definitely use some. I would also urge you to give some sources outside of chabad since there were many great Rabbis and seforim published throughout our years before chabad came along. Oh i forgot that would be assur since there is no Torah outside of chabad. Good Night.