You have yet to show how it’s nonsense.”
” Any appeal to hidden things is not at all relevant to this conversation.”
Chat,
Sorry if I did insult you, but this entire subject is nothing less than one big frustration and insulting issue.
Even more frustrating… is that you don’t seem to come across as an entire ignorant kid, nevertheless, totally confused and brainwashed.
In my world or any other reasonable person here – if one would to decide any major decision about something, we would first make sure we are total versed IN and OUT on that issue. I would be reading and studying anything available to fully understand to the best of my ability …and THEN base my decision on what I hear, know and comprehend.
YOU and many other confused neshamas decided that the Rebbe prophesied a prophecy.
Perhaps you misunderstood his words? Perhaps you misunderstood what the term Navi was meant etc?
If I were you I would would extensively study and try to answer the following and many others, before you speak.
Is there Nevuah in Chutz leAretz?
Is there a specific Lashon a Navi prophesies?
How is a Navi established?
If there is a concept of “Ruach haKodesh” which can foretell the future – what is then the significance of Navuah?
How does one become a Navi Sheker? What is a Navi Sheker all about?
Can anyone become a Navi – is Navuah tied to the Tzadik Hador?
When did Nevuah cease?
Did it gradually cease – Why did it cease?
Was there a prophecy about Nevuah ceasing?
Will Nevuah reappear again? If yes – when and how?
Are there different levels of Navuah?
Does Moshiach need to be a Navi?
If yes – what level of a Navi will he be?
“there are Halacha’s listed in the Rambam”
Fine. Lets start with the following Rambam:
לפיכך כשיבוא אדם הראוי לנבואה במלאכות השם
What does the term “אדם הראוי לנבואה” mean?
Hint: It does not mean he can preform miracles as that is what he describes later, nor does it mean Nasi Hador…