Here’s a different way to look at it- Torah Mosdos take money from the government in order to survive. So it is a way to be marbitz Torah. What a zechus for the government- the country certainly needs it. Like it or not, they are supporting Torah and those who study it.
By the way, it goes a lot further than money for yeshivos and the necessity for mass fund-raising. It includes medical care from the kuppot and National Insurance. I once met a woman in a clinic who could not continue with her treatment for lack of funds. I don’t know if this is widely done- not having medical and hospital coverage, assistance for kids with special needs, etc. is a very big deal.
About accepting money and therefore being compelled to teach anti-Torah curriculum- this is a universal problem, remember the girls’ school threatened with closure in England because they did not teach a certain accepted liberal value? At least in E”Y there is a concept of chinuch atzmai, the government actually recognizes that these schools are outside the main school system and pretty much can set their own curriculum. Every so often there is a struggle over this, but the status quo has remained and B”H the children in Chadarim and BYs are not learning anything treif. The girls BY schools, for instance, do not do bagriyot, but have their own recognized testing system. Can’t say the same, for example, for schools in NYS whose students take Regents exams.
Menu