Reply To: Why does Cholov Yisroel milk cost so much? Home › Forums › Kashruth › Why does Cholov Yisroel milk cost so much? › Reply To: Why does Cholov Yisroel milk cost so much? November 3, 2017 9:26 am at 9:26 am #1395362 JosephParticipant El Rusbo: Kosher food costs more than its non-kosher equivalent food.