” That Syag was dismissive of the fact that Gedolim support the protests by writing them off as fanatics. (I had used the term too frum.)”
too many pronouns to know what you are trying to say but distorting my words is a profession for you and I don’t appreciate it.
I couldn’t have been dismissive of the fact that Gedolim support the protests because they don’t. I did not write anyone off as fanatics, that was the wording of your choice for the example you made up with no particular relevance.
My comment was that it was a stupid question. You are asking if we would follow a gadol who tells us to act disgusting toward other people and break many many mitzvos bein adom l’chaveiro. That would never happen so its just a dumb question.
For you to TWIST that into me calling the gedolim fanatics , ch”v, is yet another disgusting ploy of yours. That people are surprised that someone like you who supports wife beating and hitting children, slapping students and supporting molestors, unless they are caught in the act by a complete Sanhedrin, is beyond me. That anyone who looks at violence as a standard mode of communication should call these protests anything but civil is no chiddish.
TLIK has it right on the mark.