” I do not presume to know what will be when Moshiach comes. ”
So what’s the point of any halachic discussion?
“All I am stating is the halachic requirements of what a Jewish Army can be comprised of”
How else?
Isn’t Halacha is written in halachic [messianic] ideal from which our sources are derived??
Rav Kook Orot b’mhalach chapter 2
[loosely and roughly translated]
The goal of Am Yisrael is to remove humanity from their yoke of their spiritual and physical troubles, and bring them a life of freedom, glory ‘Hod v’eden’, in light of the Godly ideal and bring success to all humanity.
In order to fulfill thisl, the tzibbur needs to have a commonwealth, a national sovereignty at the very height of human socio-culture”Am chacham v’navon v’hagoy hagadol (Ve’eschanan)’
And for the commonwealth to be run by the laws of God..