LessChumras: “You keep conflating registration with being drafted and claiming it is assur. Do you realize that it is only one Rav who is creating the a problem? If registration is assur, how do you explain the past 40 years all the roshai yeshivas who allowed, and continue to allow, their students to register?”
Lesschumras – you are completely misquoting/misunderstanding me. I never even discussed whether or not it’s assur to register. I explained what I wrote 3 times. I will try again.
I was pointing out (in response to someone else’s comment) that the government is</> doing something assur. The assur thing that they are doing is having an army that is not run according to halacha and drafting Jewish boys to an army that is not run according to halacha. They do draft Jewish boys to the army. I don’t know how anyone can deny that.