Reply To: Have You Ever Told Someone He/She is Jewish?

I once worked at a place that had a secretary who was marrying a Catholic and so was converting from some Protestant denomination to Catholicism. She told me that her maternal grandmother was Jewish. I told her that according to Jewish belief, that made her Jewish. This was about 40 years ago, so my memory of her reaction is a little hazy. I think she either said that’s interesting, or she said she had already been told. In any case, it didn’t change her plans.