Just want to point out that I did not intend any disrespect to R’ Shachter in my previous post, c”v.
As Takahmamash and Catchyourself pointed out, I have no reason to assume that he actually said this, and since it seems to contradict other things I’ve heard and learned, I’m assuming that there is a good chance that he didn’t.
Also, even if he did say it, the way it’s quoted in Joseph’s post, it is so theoretical as to be pretty irrelevant l’maaseh, so my post isn’t really a contradiction.
And of course, there are probably other opinions.