Reply To: Controversy In Israel – Woman says Sheva Brachos

Let me play devils advocate. Are they forbidden from making other birchas hashevach (if they hear thunder for example are they forbidden from making the bracha)?

I’ll take the other side. Heichan Matzinu that an Isha can make any brocha that requires a minyan to say it, and without a minyan we don’t say it?

Technically, Brachos on Haftorah may be an example.

You assume that the brachos are birchas hashevach. Why would an Eved or Katan not be able to make these brochos (offen EH 62:5) if that is all they are?

DY: You are assuming an aspect of “Chiyuv” where none exists.