Reply To: Hataras Nedarim Author

Sam2 and DaasYochid-This is a machlokes haposkim. Some do hold it works and some poskim hold it is symbolic, therefore you should ask a Rav. Nobody is saying it is a bad minhag, we’re just questioning if it is a real hatarah or just symbolic.

Please see the Hebrew books link I posted above.

I just have one question. What exactly is the concern of one not specifying their neder? Is it that we are concerned it is a neder that the judge won’t matir? Why would a dayan not be matir a neder?