Reply To: Har HaBayis Revisited

american_yerushalmi:

There is not the slightest doubt as to what Rav Elyashiv held on this matter.

Is that so?

So, have you any clue why he held that ascension is assur – except what you have read here, in TYW, that it was because of political reasons (incitement)?

Where has he written a responsa on the matter? an we examine his sources and discuss them, as is the traditional Torah way of deciding the halachah?

So, this is how we decide halachah? No discussion of the issues, no Gemaras, no Rishonim, no Acharonim, no Responsa, no live Poskim. Just reports from a posek’s “sons and loyal talmidim,” and from tirades of Moshe Gafni in the Knesset, and from newspaper articles!

And you have the nerve to call this halachah.