Reply To: American Pharoah: Kiddush Hashem or Not

Home Forums In The News American Pharoah: Kiddush Hashem or Not Reply To: American Pharoah: Kiddush Hashem or Not

#1093346
☕ DaasYochid ☕
Participant

I believe they made both a kiddush Hashem and a chillul Hashem.

A kiddush Hashem was made in that they didn’t drive there on Shabbos.

A chillul Hashem was caused by the issurim d’rabbonon which were violated. I do think amira l’akum is an issue; it’s assur to ride a b’heima on Shabbos. The prize money is schar Shabbos. There may be workarounds (e.g. a shtar mechirah) but I haven’t heard such a thing, and at the least it would be maris ayin.

Someone (ZD?) pointed out that the whole idea of involvement in the gambling business is improper. I hear the tayna.

I’ve seen some try to say that shvisas b’hemto is an issue, but I don’t think any melachah was done by the b’heima.

I’m pretty sure Kapusta isn’t too happy that this thread was posted. 🙁