DY, I wrote “Violating dina demalchusa dina for a questionable chumra is irrational. Making it more difficult for some mothers to accomplish their responsibilities when they are already nshei chayil binding the community together is illogical. And I find the way that the message was finessed and then walked back to be dishonest.”
Though I clearly do not agree with R Vosner’s take, the examples I gave for illogical, irrational, and dishonest were all about the application.