“Showjoe answers yes to the original question, to which I say: Says which posek? I wouldn’t just assume this.”
my previous post was badly worded and did not reflect my intentions. when i saw my post tonight, even before i saw your post, i cringed, realizing that my words meant something other then my intentions.
i did not mean to pasken the shaila, rather i meant to give my viewpoint and to say that this would lechora be the answer.
the last sentence of my last post should have said “so therefore the L”H would be non-anonymous type and according to this theory be assur.”