Sam: His star pupil who he holds out as such to the whole world is a blazing apikores who publicly denies torah is min hashamayim, and the person he picked to replace himself at YCT defends him. I don’t think I am off by ascribing the opinions to him.
Rabbi Avi Weiss is no clown. He has done far more for Am Yisrael than any anonymous internet commentator.
I am makir tov for the advocacy he has done on behalf of jews, in Russia and elsewhere. That doesn’t make him a maamin.