Before delving into the intricacies of this debate, I would like to point out that even a cursory view of the various meforshim reveal numerous different interpretations of the way to treat the ‘Wicked Son’. These include many different interpretations of ‘blunt his teeth’, one of which I saw last night that took it to mean that we endeavour to excite his curiosity so that he will ask less scornfully, and be more receptive. This is just one of many examples of ways in which the entire chelek takes on an entirely different tone, in this instance meaning anything but being harsh. So whilst your query is still pertinent and a very interesting subject to look into, it’s worth reminding there’s more than one way to read it. So whilst there is plenty to talk about, assuming an haskafik standpoint is, at best difficult.
Menu