PAA-“Therefore, it weakens your case that it is categorically assur.”
No it doesn’t! Anymore than if s/o Paskins like Bais Shammy over Bais Hillel. Or the Mechaber over the Rema!
“I never said we should. I said that it’s a machlokes and therefore not as pashut as you made it out yo be.”
It is so Pashut; as I just explained!