Reply To: giving tzedakah to aniyim who smoke

Home Forums Decaffeinated Coffee giving tzedakah to aniyim who smoke Reply To: giving tzedakah to aniyim who smoke

#1067102
writersoul
Participant

I actually was faced with the sheilah once of whether I should return cigarettes to a smoker.

On the one hand:

They were in a place where the person would find them if I did not return them

He used to smoke in such a way that many people (including me) were forced to spend hours inhaling the second-hand smoke

He had other cigarettes at that moment

Lifnei iver?

On the other hand:

Hashavas aveidah

He would keep smoking no matter what I did

I believe (IIRC) that I was told to return them.

I read a great teshuva from the YU roshei yeshiva that would assur smoking. I don’t remember if it touched the lifnei iver aspect.

I know that my grandfather used to smoke and was told by R Moshe that bemetzius he should not smoke so he stopped.

Lung cancer is not pretty.

(I am aware that very little of what I just wrote is germane as far as the matter at hand is concerned- I just have very strong opinions on smoking. The week after a relative of mine passed away of lung cancer I literally yelled at a yeshiva guy who was smoking. SO yeah.

My friend had to actually drag me away.

And he was also wearing a Kahane Tzadak sticker so that didn’t really help matters.

Boy, everyone will know who I am now…)