Home › Forums › Controversial Topics › Are Women Really Jewish? › Reply To: Are Women Really Jewish?
November 10, 2011 2:01 pm at 2:01 pm
#1065048
BTGuy
Participant
YW Moderator – 42. I beg to differ. Your syllogism is neither simple nor logic.
Your categorical propositions, from which your conclusion is to be inferred, do not contain the very necessary defined structure of including, “All”, “Some”, or “No”. For example, “All” Michele Obamas are….or “Some” Michele Obamas are….. or “No” Michele Obamas are……Therefore…yadda yadda yadda….would make for valid propositions that can then be argued.
They are structurally incomplete and logically leading us to a faulty, albeit, humorous conclusion.
Nonetheless, I am just the messenger. You will have to take it up with Aristotle. It’s his gig. lol