Tora Umadda-
Is there anybody who saw the Maharil in teshuvos Chadashos and still thinks mesorah is a valid tayneh? Do you have any reason to believe the roshei yeshiva know the Maharil? I recently showed it to my RY and he was maskim you can’t be soimech on a (safek) beis haleivi lkula kneged it. The sefer was recently printed. The Bais Haleivi never saw it. If Achronim who say a shitta kneged rishonim they did not know, certainly it is not a valid shittah and we always say ???? ??? ??? ????
And there is no 2 ways of understanding it. I quoted the leshonos above.
Also ???? it is a machlokes if Nignaz means forever. We find many times that if metzious is muchach one way than the metzious can be machriah. The rayos to the Murex are overwhelming, so it is a raya muchachos to the maharil