But how could you even suggest that that creates a mesorah to not keep the Torah?! I didn’t claim that as a reason [in it’s general form the way you are presenting it]. And the comparison to Shabbos and the Holocaust is beyond absurd. To point out a few of the glaring canyons separating them from techeiles: 1- chiyuv misah; 2- an issur which 2b- has an attendant action vs a non-issur that is passive in nature; 3- a few years of “mitzva loss” vs hundreds; 4- the nature of the conditions that caused the “loss”. etc, etc, etc, etc.
Menu