Reply To: Techeiles 🔵❎🐌☑️🐟

“They are chemically identical in color. but the chemical that comes from the Murux has a stronger cleavage and will stay on stronger.”

I’m not sure what that means. I assume chemically identical means the same chemicals.

” Now the gemara gives us a test that should make the kla ilan should come off. But it doesn’t. So this is not a question on the techeiles but a question on kla ilan.”

Actually it would prove that they are doing the test wrong.

” but Rav Schachter holds that since we have the real Techeilis nowadays it’s better to not wear Tzitzis at all than to wear Tzitzis without Techeiles.”

You first have to prove that it is the real techeiles.

” But what i am prooving from the bleach is that there still is a chiluk between kla ilan and the murex in the strenth of the dye.”

As far as I know the Gemara’s test does not mention anything about bleach.