Reply To: Abbaye vs. Rava and Rav vs. R' Yochanan

Pixelate:

The Maadnei Yom Tov is asking on Tosafos’s question. Ain Hachi Nami Tosafos’s answer would answer the question if it ever was a question in the first place. Also Tosafos’s answer doesn’t help for R’ Amram; it only helps for Tosafos’s question at the end.

Regarding your second point that was gufa one of the reasons why Tosafos rejected Rashi’s pshat.