Reply To: The new Jerusalem expansion – how do you feel about a Pal state

OK so then it’s not shiyach to argue with them on line? sure i know its’ time wasting anyway. Also I am talking about land that has been taken by the state. Actually i lived there during the beginning of the settlements. One of my neighbors was into it, and he told me all about it’s glory

OK so you’re saying its all Jewish land every inch of it, not just what was bought.

I do agree that why there can’t be if Jews want to live amongst them, why not.

My issue is the timing of this. and the problem of ruling over all these people is a problem in real terms.

We also don’t know what would have happened had there not been settlements.

I do remember very good relations with Arabs in Sharon towns that hugged their towns, people going back and forth. We really don’t know what would have been without settlements. I refer mostly to West bank ones.

It became a thorn, an incitement. you say they would have found another herring. I don’t know.

I do know things were very peaceful in the 70’s there.

And I do understand a pal person would like to live someday in a real state with his own folks running it.