Think outside the box.
If she’s not into jewelery, then find something else. Who cares if it’s not “traditional.” Does she have a favorite classic book? Find a first edition of it. Does she enjoy hiking? Buy a nice pair of hiking boots.
The point is this: choose a gift that will show your kallah that you thought about her and the type of gift that would please her, and that you’re willing to buck conventional standards for her.
The Wolf