Reply To: What does it mean to be yeshivish?

I like popa’s answer the best, but I don’t know about purporting to be the establishment.

I think there are a lot of parts and perspectives to the definition of yeshivish. I don’t think one can easily define it objectively. When asking the question “is he yeshivish?” or “how yeshivish is he”, you have to know who you are asking, and to answer in any meaningful way, you have to know who’s asking.