Reply To: How would you respond to Savage on Metzitzah

Home Forums Controversial Topics How would you respond to Savage on Metzitzah Reply To: How would you respond to Savage on Metzitzah

#1028004
gavra_at_work
Participant

DY: Modeh. I didn’t think anyone else could do the Mitzva, but realize you are correct that Avraham Avinu’s Eved is a Bar Chiyuva.

Rambam Milah 2:1

??????, ?????????? ??????: ?????????? ??????? ??????? ??????? ????????? ???????, ????????? ??????? ???? ?????.

Looking at the Rambam in 2:2-2:4, it wouldd seem that even though Priyah is Meakev, Metziza is not (as he just says “??????????? ??????”, not ” ????????? ??? ???”). Is there anyone who holds Metziza is an Ikuv in the Mitzva? Nafka Mina is exactly my point, do you need a Bar Chiyuva to do the Metziza or not?