Reply To: Million Man Atzeres

Home Forums In The News Million Man Atzeres Reply To: Million Man Atzeres

#1020518

MMA

koldmamadaka:

While I definitely understand how it can be emotionally difficult to know that your son is risking his life to serve his country while others are not, you must realize intellectually that there are many jobs that that do not entail any risk to life and limb are also crucial to the country. For instance, can one reasonably claim that a soldier operating an Iron Dome battery in the heart of Tel Aviv is serving his country any less than an infantryman? Are both of them not ensuring the safety of their fellow Jews?

And is the Torah not at least as important in ensuring the safety and continuity of the Jewish People as is the Iron Dome, and therefore just at least as worthy of state support?

What is hypocritical about believing that a life dedicated to Torah contributes at least as much to the safety and continuity of the Jewish People as serving 36 months in the IDF does?

rc:

Wow. What a snide, derogatory, spiteful, and above all false generalization. You should be ashamed of yourself.

DaMoshe: