Reply To: Non-jewish A Capella During Sefira

Git: Your translation of “Simcha” as “enjoyment” is not correct. And no, we are discussing whether “Halachah clearly dictates that any type of music causes us enjoyment and makes us happy”. You, apparently, see no need for discussion as you know everything here so much so that you think a discussion of the topic is inappropriate. Halachah is not Ish Kol HaYashar B’einav Ya’aseh. It’s a discussion because you can’t just come out of nowhere and think you know everything, certainly without a source. The Maskana of the discussion might be like you. But it is not inappropriate to try and actually determine the Halachah. That is ridiculous.