netazar:
See Rabbi Soloveichik’s own Chamesh Drashos and the gedolim’s views about him and his ideologies.
DaMoshe:
Zionism is not pertinent to this discussion at this time.
The source of “justifying” is not only Broyde and his questionable piece, but Rabbi Soloveichik himself.
Sam2:
It seems that this wasn’t the only fake person Broyde “created”, but that’s not the only point.
See Rav Shlomo Miller’s scathing response to Broyde’s piece. Rav Miller clearly states that Broyde’s piece is wrong and that the arichus is “hevel uRius ruach”.