TruthSharer:
People repeat your question all the time. It is noteworthy, then, that Slifkin has not criticized his science significantly (actually, I don’t remember him doing so at all. I’m just covering myself there in case someone has a better memory than me).
I think that the fact that people even ask the question is only because they think that R’ Meiselman’s book is like most other Science and Chazal books, which is untrue.