The fiercely contested Iran nuclear deal will likely survive in Congress despite unified GOP opposition and some Democratic defections, the top Senate Republican says. That would mean a major foreign policy win for President Barack Obama.
Obama has “a great likelihood of success,” Senate Majority Leader Mitch McConnell said in his home state of Kentucky this week — giving public voice to what other Republicans have acknowledged in private. “I hope we can defeat it, but the procedure is obviously stacked in the president’s favor.”
Indeed, even as Congress’ August recess has hardened Republicans’ opposition to the deal on Capitol Hill and on the presidential campaign trail, reality is setting in: They probably can’t stop it. Significant Democratic defections from Obama would be required in both chambers of Congress, and even with opponents mounting a strenuous lobbying campaign in key congressional districts, such a prospect looks remote.
That means that even with Obama firmly in lame-duck territory and his GOP opponents in control of Congress and aiming for the White House, the president is on the verge of a legacy-defining victory on a pact that he and his supporters say will keep the world safe from Iran’s nuclear ambitions. Opponents continue to warn furiously that the result could be just the opposite: to strengthen Tehran’s hand, in an existential threat to Israel and the world.
On Tuesday a second Democratic senator, Bob Menendez of New Jersey, did announce his opposition to the deal, joining Chuck Schumer of New York.
“The agreement that has been reached failed to achieve the one thing it set out to achieve — it failed to stop Iran from becoming a nuclear weapons state at a time of its choosing,” Menendez said in a blistering speech at the Seton Hall School of Diplomacy and International Relations in East Orange, New Jersey. “In fact, it authorizes and supports the very road map Iran will need to arrive at its target.”
Menendez argued the deal should be sent back and negotiations should continue. But his opposition was expected, and, underscoring slim prospects for his side, he stopped short of predicting opponents would prevail.
The agreement would require Iran to dismantle most of its nuclear program for at least a decade in exchange for billions of dollars in relief from international sanctions. But the Israeli government and critics in the U.S. argue that it would not stop Iran from building a bomb.
Bipartisan legislation does give Congress the right to review the deal, and there will be a vote by Sept. 17. That’s likely to go in favor of disapproval, but Obama would then veto the legislation and opponents would need to muster two-thirds majorities in both chambers to override him.
Obama needs support from 34 of the 46 members of the Democratic caucus to sustain a veto, and 23 have already announced they are backing him. Sens. Jack Reed and Sheldon Whitehouse of Rhode Island issued a joint release in support of the president Tuesday just hours after Menendez declared his opposition. In the House, 146 of the 188 Democrats are necessary to sustain a veto, and more than 50 have expressed their support for the accord, compared to 10 opponents.
From his vacation home on Martha’s Vineyard, Obama has been lobbying the undecided. The White House said Obama has talked individually or in small groups with nearly 100 lawmakers since the deal was announced last month, with Cabinet and senior administration officials reaching out to dozens more.
“We remain confident that ultimately a majority of Democrats in both the House and the Senate will support the deal, and if necessary, sustain the president’s veto,” White House spokesman Eric Schultz said Tuesday.
Liberal and progressive groups are joining in the lobbying, while opponents on the right including the American Israel Public Affairs Committee are spending millions to try to build opposition.
Any chance of the White House winning GOP support for the deal in Congress evaporated in recent days as Sen. Jeff Flake of Arizona, who had been seen as a possible “yes” vote, declared he would vote “no.” Sen. Bob Corker of Tennessee, the chairman of the Foreign Relations Committee, announced his opposition in an opinion piece Tuesday in the Washington Post, and House Speaker John Boehner of Ohio has been criticizing the deal as he travels the country by bus raising money for Republican lawmakers.
But the deal has picked up scattered support from Republicans outside of Congress, including former Sen. Richard Lugar of Indiana, who chaired the Foreign Relations Committee, and former Treasury Secretary Hank Paulson. Predictions that the issue would dominate Congress’ August recess have yet to come true, and Obama still finds himself in a strong position to prevail.
“It’s not easy to override a president’s veto when the president is so committed to getting this done, and really the White House is fighting very hard for every vote in Congress,” former Democrat-turned-independent Sen. Joe Lieberman, who is helping marshal opposition, said in an interview Tuesday. But Lieberman said there were still enough undecided votes to get to two-thirds, and “we’re working hard on them.”
(AP)
7 Responses
This spells doom to this country and everyone in between. I guess this president if he’s fierce enough to get elected a second term after almost bringing down this country then he can pull this thru as well. As for us Jews אין לנו אלא על אבינו שבשמים . My dear brothers open your eyes and hearts don’t you see the final straw before mashiach. If you do a little research on the news you will find reported that for a while I have been hearing the sound of the trumpet in heaven and the higher hemispheres. The Gemara says ובשביעית קולות and some make the connection. The Gemara in Yuma explicitly discusses by the end of the day’s war between Edom and paras which is Iran. There is so much more you just have to open your eyes and heart and long for the geula. Start living a live for למענך אלוקים חיים let’s stop doing thing for ourself only do Torah and Mitzvos for כבוד שמים and behold we will meet soon in the Bais Hamikdash very soon. See you there soon Amein
You can google sounds from heaven
Today’s Hamevaser brings a report by the Research Division of Israeli Military Intelligence which says that there are positive dimensions to the deal: It contains signficant achievements for stopping Iran from developing nuclear weapons and it will restrain Iran in everything involving terrorist activity in the world. “There are not a few good perspectives in the nuclear agreement, for example the fact that it provides for dialogue between Iran and the US on regional issues in the mid-East such as the civil war in Syria.” Recently dozens of retired Israeli generals signed a letter to Netanyahu telling him to stop fighting the deal, which is already a fait accompli, so that he can position himself and his country to have more input into how the deal is implemented. Another recent report said that even if Congress does override Obama’s expected veto (which is at this point at best an uncertainty) he will still have a lot of executive power to implement a lot of the deal in spite of Congress’s objections, and since all the other signators to the deal (Russia, China, Europeans) will go ahead with it anyway the deal is indeed pretty much a fait accompli. And most of the Israeli military and intelligence community is saying that the deal is Israeli’s best option and far from a disaster …
But it will be surviving not as the law of the land or a formal obligation of the United States, but only as a policy of current president that isn’t legally or morally binding on any future president. Only a treaty, ratified by the Senate, is law.
Don’t lose heart. It is not over until the actual vote is taken. We are already seeing cracks in the agreement. Russia is selling missles, despite U.S. objections. So exactly what is the agreement worth now? It is time for everyone to write letters and put pressure on politicians to act responsibly. Rabbi Avigdor Miller ZT”L, used to encourage people to write on a variety of issues. One of his most famous pieces of advice was that never underestimate the power of a letter as long as it is respectful. Take Senator Kirsten Gillibrand. Although she has come out in support of the agreement, she didn’t vote yet. If an overwhelming barrage of mail goes to Gillibrand voicing objections because of Russia’s actions, Do you think that she won’t waver? After all, she too must run for reelection.
151 Democrats in the House of Representatives signed a letter favoring the Iran deal a few months ago. None have flipped. It only takes 146 to sustain a veto.
Back in February a bill to *increase* sanctions on Iran would have passed Congress by a veto-proof majority. Then Netanyahu gave his speech. Netanyahu should reconsider his hardball tactics. They aren’t working.
3 you believe in santa claus and the tooth fairy